Outcome Studies in the Field of Pastoral Counselling: A Focused Review of Research Published between 1990 and 2020
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24193/subbtref.70.2.16Keywords:
pastoral counselling, pastoral care, outcome, impact, effectiveness, efficacy, religion, spirituality, evidence-basedAbstract
This literature review examines the empirical evidence of the impact of pastoral care, focusing on the areas that have been studied in terms of measurable and verifiable outcomes. By analysing 34 international studies published between 1990 and 2020, we assessed the methodological diversity and empirical depth of research in this field. The review encompasses qualitative, quantitative, and mixed-method studies alike, including small- and large-sample investigations. Our findings suggest that while the impact of pastoral counselling is empirically measurable and verifiable, significant methodological limitations persist, particularly regarding measurement precision and the identification of influencing factors. Compared to psychotherapies integrating religiosity and spirituality, pastoral care research is less extensive and often based on smaller, less differentiated samples, with limited attention to the professional competence levels of care providers. Most outcome studies have been conducted in hospital contexts involving patients with physical or mental health conditions and their relatives. Results highlight the need for further empirical work using more rigorous and diversified methodological approaches, broader research settings, and assessment tools adapted to the qualification level of pastoral care providers, in order to establish a more comprehensive and evidence-based understanding of pastoral care effectiveness.
References
BAY, Paul S. – BECKMAN, Daniel – TRIPPI, James – GUNDERMAN, Richard –TERRY, Colin (2008): The Effect of Pastoral Care Services on Anxiety, Depression, Hope, Religious Coping, and Religious Problem Solving Styles: A Randomized Controlled Study. In: Journal of Religion and Health. 47, 1. 57–69.
BINGAMAN, Kirk A. (2015): When Acceptance Is the Road to Growth and Healing: Incorporating the Third Wave of Cognitive Therapies into Pastoral Care and Counselling. In: Pastoral Psychology. 64, 5. 567–579.
CAPTARI, Laura E. – HOOK, Joshua N. – HOYT, William – DAVIS, Don E. – MCELROY-HELTZEL, Stacey E. – WORTHINGTON, Everett L. (2018): Integrating Clients’ Religion and Spirituality within Psychotherapy: A Comprehensive Meta-analysis. In: Journal of Clinical Psychology. 74, 11. 1938–1951.
CARR, John C. (2015): The Evolution of Research Paradigms in Pastoral/Spiritual Care, Counselling, and Education. In: Journal of Pastoral Care & Counselling. 69, 4. 232–239.
CHAMBLESS, Dianne, L. – HOLLON, Steven D. (1998): Defining Empirically Supported Therapies. In: Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 66, 1. 7–18.
CHENEY, Gregory J. (2018): Integrating Pastoral and Clinical Identities: A Narrative Inquiry of Pastoral Counsellors. In: Journal of Pastoral Care & Counselling. 72, 3.172–179.
CHENG, Joy – PURCELL, Hillary N. – DIMITRIOU, Sophia M. – GROSSOEHME, Daniel H. (2015): Testing the Feasibility and Acceptability of a Chaplaincy Intervention to Improving Treatment Attitudes and Self-efficacy of Adolescents with Cystic Fibrosis: A Pilot Study. In: Journal of Health Care Chaplaincy. 21, 2. 76–90.
CONROY, Natalia (2019): Between Theology and Care: What Does It Mean To Be a Hospital Chaplain? In: Zhurnal Issledovanii Sotsial’noi Politiki. 17, 3. 375–390.
CURRIER, Joseph M. – STEVENS, Laura T. – ISAAK, Steven L. – SMITH, Tracey – ZLOMKE, Kimberly (2020): Understanding Preferences for Addressing Spirituality Among Adults Seeking Outpatient Mental Health Care. In: The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease. 208, 6. 514–516.
DAMEN, Annelieke – SCHUHMANN, Carmen – LEGET, Carlo – FITCHETT, George (2020): Can Outcome Research Respect the Integrity of Chaplaincy? A Review of Outcome Studies. In: Journal of Health Care Chaplaincy. 26, 4. 131–158.
DERRICKSON, Paul – VAN HISE, Angelina (2009): Curriculum for a Spiritual Pathway Project: Integrating Research Methodology into Pastoral Care Training. In: Journal of Health Care Chaplaincy. 16, 1–2. 3–12.
ELIASON, Grafton Todd – LEPORE, Mark – HOLMES, Douglas (2013): Ethics in Pastoral Care and Counselling: A Contemporary Review of Updated Standards in the Field. In: Journal of Pastoral Care & Counselling. 67, 2. 1–11.
EYSENCK, Hans Jürgen (1983): The Benefits of Psychotherapy: M.L. Smith, G.V. Glass and T.I. Miller: Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, Maryland (1980). In: Behaviour Research and Therapy. 21, 3. 315–320.
FLANNELLY, Kevin J. – EMANUEL, Linda L. – HANDZO, George F. – GALEK, Kathleen, SILTON, Nava R. – CARLSON, Melissa (2012): A National Study of Chaplaincy Services and End-of-life Outcomes. In: BMC Palliative Care. 11, 1. 10.
FLANNELLY, Kevin J. – GALEK, Kathleen – TANNENBAUM, Helen P. – HANDZO, George F. (2007): A Preliminary Proposal for a Scale to Measure the Effectiveness of Pastoral Care with Family Members of Hospitalized Patients. In: The Journal of Pastoral Care & Counselling. 61, 1–2. 19–29.
FLANNELLY, Kevin. J. – OETTINGER, Margaret – GALEK, Kathleen – BRAUN-STORCK, Arnd – KREGER, Ralph (2009): The Correlates of Chaplains’ Effectiveness in Meeting the Spiritual/Religious and Emotional Needs of Patients. In: Journal of Pastoral Care & Counselling. 63, 1–2. 1–16.
FREDERICK, Thomas V. (2009): Models of Psychotherapy: Implications for Pastoral Care Practice. In: Pastoral Psychology. 58, 4. 351–363.
GALEK, Kathleen – FLANNELLY, Kevin J. – JANKOWSKI, Katherine R. – HANDZO, George F. (2011): A Methodological Analysis of Chaplaincy Research: 2000–2009. In: Journal of Health Care Chaplaincy. 17, 3–4. 126–145.
HAUSMANN, Eugene – SPOONER, Mary (2009): Does Pastoral Counselling Work? A Pilot Study of Delinquent Boys. In: The Journal of Pastoral Care & Counselling. 63, 3–4. 4–1.
HOOK, Joshua N. – WORTHINGTON Everett L. – DAVIS, Don E. – JENNINGS, David J. – GARTNER, Aubrey L. – HOOK, Jan P. (2010): Empirically Supported Religious and Spiritual Therapies. In: Journal of Clinical Psychology. 66, 1. 46–72.
JANKOWSKI, Katherine R. – HANDZO, George F. – FLANNELLY, Kevin J. (2011): Testing the Efficacy of Chaplaincy Care. In: Journal of Health Care Chaplaincy. 17, 3–4. 100–125.
KEVERN, Peter – HILL, Lisa (2015): ‘Chaplains for Well-Being’ in Primary Care: Analysis of the Results of a Retrospective Study. In: Primary Health Care Research & Development. 16, 1. 87–99.
KOENIG, Harold G. (2012): Religion, Spirituality, and Health: The Research and Clinical Implications. In: ISRN Psychiatry. 2012. 278730.
KURITA, Akira – TAKASE, Bonpei – SHINAGAWA, Naosuke – KODANI, Eitaro – OKADA, Kaoru – IWAHARA, Shinichiro – KUSAMA, Yoshiki – ATARASHI, Hirotsugu (2011): Spiritual Activation in Very Elderly Individuals Assessed as Heart Rate Variability and Plasma IL/10/IL–6 Ratios. In: International Heart Journal. 52, 5. 299–303.
LAMBERT, Michael – GREGERSEN, Ann T. – BURLINGAME, Gary M. (2004): The Outcome Questionnaire-45. In: MARUISH, Mark E. (ed.): The Use of Psychological Testing for Treatment Planning and Outcomes Assessment: Instruments for Adults. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers. 191–234.
LEE SMITH, Mary – GLASS, Gene V. – MILLER, Thomas I. (1981): The Benefits of Psychotherapy. Baltimore – London, Johns Hopkins University Press.
LUCAS, Arthur M. (2001): Introduction to the Discipline for Pastoral Care Giving. In: Journal of Health Care Chaplaincy. 10, 2. 1–33.
MARIN, Deborah B. – SHARMA, Vanshdeep – SOSUNOV, Eugene – EGOROVA, Natalia – GOLDSTEIN, Rafael – HANDZO, George F. (2015): Relationship between Chaplain Visits and Patient Satisfaction. In: Journal of Health Care Chaplaincy. 21, 1. 14–24.
PESUT, Barbara – SINCLAIR, Shane – FITCHETT, George – GREIG, Madeleine – KOSS, Sarah E. (2016): Health Care Chaplaincy: A Scoping Review of the Evidence 2009–2014. In: Journal of Health Care Chaplaincy. 22, 2. 67–84.
PIDERMAN, Katherine M. – RADECKI BREITKOPF, Carmen – JENKINS, Sarah M. – EUERLE, Terin T. – LOVEJOY, Laura A. – KWETE, Gracia M. – JATOI, Aminah (2015): A Chaplain-Led Spiritual Life Review Pilot Study for Patients with Brain cancers and Other Degenerative Neurologic Diseases. In: Rambam Maimonides Medical Journal. 6, 2. e0015.
RAFFAY, Julian – WOOD, Emily – TODD, Andrew (2016): Service User Views of Spiritual and Pastoral Care (Chaplaincy) in NHS Mental Health Services: A Co-produced Constructivist Grounded Theory Investigation. In: BMC Psychiatry. 16. 200.
TADWALKAR, Rigwed – UDEOJI, Dioma U. – WEINER, Rabbi Jason – AVESTRUZ, Father Lester – LACHANCE, Denise – PHAN, Anita – NGUYEN, David – BHARADWAJ, Parag – SCHWARZ, Ernst R. (2014): The Beneficial Role of Spiritual Counselling in Heart Failure Patients. In: Journal of Religion and Health. 53, 5. 1575–1585.
TOWNSEND, Loren L. (2011): Research Report: A Grounded Theory Description of Pastoral Counselling. In: The Journal of Pastoral Care & Counselling. 65, 3–4. 1–15.
WILSON, Jo Clare (2002): Attention to the Scientific Benefits of Pastoral Care Is a Blessing and a Curse. In: Journal of Health Care Chaplaincy. 13, 1. 237–244.
WORTHINGTON, Everett L. – HOOK, Joshua N. – DAVIS, Don E. – MCDANIEL, Michael A. (2011): Religion and Spirituality. In: Journal of Clinical Psychology. 67, 2. 204–214.
WORTHINGTON, Everett L. – KURUSU, Taro A. – MCCOLLOUGH, Michael E. – SANDAGE, Steven J. (1996): Empirical Research on Religion and Psychotherapeutic Processes and Outcomes: A 10-Year Review and Research Prospectus. In: Psychological Bulletin. 119. 448–487.
ZIMMERMAN, George L. – MEIER, Augustine (1999): Outcomes in Pastoral Counselling. In: American Journal of Pastoral Counselling. 2, 2. 67–88.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Studia Universitatis Babes-Bolyai Theologia Reformata Transylvanica
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
