Identity perspectives regarding Israeli-Arab youth participating in voluntary national service in Israel
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24193/subbeuropaea.2025.1.09Keywords:
Voluntary national service, multiculturalism, identity dissonance, arab minority in Israel, minority integrationAbstract
This article examines the perspective of Israeli-Arab youth regarding their participation in Voluntary National Service (VNS) within the context of Israel's political landscape. VNS is an alternative to mandatory military service to foster social integration and civic responsibility. However, for Israeli-Arab youth, VNS often leads to significant identity conflict, shaped by Israel's characterization as a Jewish and democratic state and ongoing regional tensions. The article identifies various factors contributing to this identity conflict through a comprehensive literature review. The finding offers insights for policymakers seeking to foster a more inclusive environment for Israeli-Arab citizens.
References
1. Abutbul Selinger, Guy (2024), “The construction of dual ethnic identity among multi-ethnic adolescents” in Current Sociology, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/00113921241275682.
2. Adres, Eitan; Vanhuysse, Pieter; Vashdi, Dana (2012), “The individual’s level of globalism and citizen commitment to the state: The tendency to evade military service in Israel”, Armed Forces & Society, no. 38, 92-116.
3. Al-Rawi, Ahmed (2018), “Regional television and collective ethnic identity: Investigating the SNS outlets of Arab TV shows”, Social Media +Society, no. 4, 1-16.
4. Ari, Esra (2020), “Multiculturalism: An antidote to racism or untouched inequalities? A comparative study of second-generation Jamaicans and second-generation Portuguese in Toronto”, International Network on Youth Integration (INYI) Journal, no. 7, 4-11.
5. Bartal, Shaul (2024), “The Palestinian youth of East Jerusalem – between Palestinian and Israeli identity”, Middle Eastern Studies, no. 60, 1-12.
6. Beaman, Lori G. (2024), “From religious citizen to multicultural citizen: Changing conceptualizations of citizenship and belonging in Canada”, Education, Citizenship and Social Justice, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/17461979241227845.
7. Bick, Etta (2016), “Lip-service to service: the Knesset debates over civic national service in Israel 1977–2007”, Israel Affairs, no. 22, 126-149.
8. Blit Cohen, Edith; Essa, Mays (2022), “Palestinian-Arabs volunteering in state institutions in Israel: Reconciliation and peacebuilding or conflict and suspicion?”, Peace and Conflict Studies, no. 29, 1-26.
9. Bohunická, Alena (2022), “Civic rhetoric and social inclusion”, Journal of Linguistics/Jazykovedný Casopis, no. 73, 51-64.
10. Boucher, François; Guérard de Latour, Sophie; Baycan-Herzog, Esma (2023), “Rethinking liberal multiculturalism: Foundations, practices, and methodologies”, Ethnicities, no. 23, 1-18.
11. Chin, Clayton (2019), “The concept of belonging: Critical, normative and multicultural”, Ethnicities, no. 19, 715-739.
12. Crepaz, Marcus (2024), “Ethnic hierarchies versus civic values in a community of descent: Evidence from an interactive survey experiment in Germany” in Nations and Nationalism, no. 30, 649-665.
13. Diab, Ahmad Baker; B., Shdema, Ilan; Schnell, Izhak (2022), “Arab integration in new and established mixed cities in Israel”, Urban Studies, no. 59, 1800-1818.
14. Dubrovin, V; Solovarovа, Y. N (2020), “Problematization of ethnic context and socio-political cases of multiculturalism”, The Kazan Socially-Humanitarian Bulletin, no. 11, 9-15.
15. Emmenegger, Heidi (2018), “Multicultural policy: Nigeria, Canada, and Switzerland”, The Equilibrium, no. 4, https://escholarship.org/uc/item/8wr6p1fg.
16. Feinstein, Yuval (2019), “Influential in its absence: The relationship between refusing to embrace sub-national ethnic identities and openness to inter-national coexistence among Jews and Arab/ Palestinians in Israel”, Ethnicities, no. 19, 390-413.
17. Gahramanova, Aytan (2006), “Identity conflicts and its implications for conflict management”, Revista UNISCI, no. 11, 153-186.
18. Gal, Reuven (2008), Position paper: Perception of the Issue of Israeli Arab Citizens' Rights and Obligations in the Face of the Voluntary National Service Idea, Tel Aviv University [In Hebrew].
19. Genkova, Petia et al. (2022), “A comparative study on culture-specific and cross-cultural aspects of intercultural relations in Hungary, Serbia, Czech Republic, and Germany”, Frontiers in Psychology, no. 13, 1-16.
20. Golan, Oren; Ben-Ari, Eyal (2018), “Armed forces, cyberspace, and global images: The official website of the Israeli Defense Forces 2007–2015”, Armed Forces & Society, no. 44, 280-300.
21. Khatib, Ibrahim (2021), “Attitudes of Indigenous minority leaders toward political events in their trans-state national group: Between identity, conflict, and values”, Nationalism and Ethnic Politics, no. 27, 149-168.
22. Kidron, Anat (2023), “Local Communities and Separate Space: The Zionist Stance on Jewish Settlement in Arab Cities - The Case of Acre”, Journal of Urban History, no. 49, 1243-1262.
23. Kymlicka, Will (1995), Multicultural citizenship: A liberal theory of minority rights, Oxford University Press.
24. Lim, Hwee Ling et al. (2021), “Emirati parents’ attitudes toward the military and national service in the United Arab Emirates”, Asian Journal of Humanities and Social Studies, no. 9, 203-213.
25. Meler, Tal (2023), “I represent the police I represent the state – justification work following ethno-national boundaries crossing among Arab female police officers in Israel” in Frontiers in Sociology, 81, https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/sociology/articles/10.3389/fsoc.2023.1296790/full.
26. Muminov, Nurlan (2023), “Redefining Israeli National Identity: Understanding the role of militarism and settler-colonialism”, Etnosayasat, no. 1, https://journal.etnosayasat.kz/index.php/etp/article/view/8/8.
27. Nir, Tal; Perry-Hazan, Lotem (2025), “Realizing participation rights of minority youth in conflicted societies: The case of councils integrating Jewish and Palestinian-Arab youth in Israel”, Youth & Society, no. 57, 56-79.
28. Peleg, Ilan (2020), “Majority-Minority Relations in Deeply Divided Democratic Societies” in Aronof, Yael S; Peleg, Ilan; Sarsar, Saliba (eds.), Continuity and Change in Political Culture: Israel and Beyond, Lexington Books, 117-136.
29. Popescu, Bogdan G; Jugl, Marlene (2024), “Civic associations, populism, and (un-)civic behavior: evidence from Germany”, Political Science Research and Methods, no. 13, 1-17.
30. Rass, Rida Abu (2024), “The two-pronged Palestinian response to exclusion within Israel”, Palestine/Israel Review, no. 1, 421-453.
31. Rozental, Tamir (2023), “The influence of public demographics in Israel on the perception of CSR of Mega companies”, Entrepreneurship, no. 11, 98-107.
32. Shdema, Ilan; Martin, Deborah G. (2022), “Place identity among native minorities: Lessons from Arabs in Israel”, Geographical Review, no. 112, 286-305.
33. Sherer, Moshe, (2004), “National service in Israel: Motivations, volunteer characteristics, and content levels”, Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, no. 33, 94-108.
34. Skriver, Jennifer Ann; Jensen, Julie Borup (2024), “Mechanisms of inclusion and exclusion: Illuminating the dynamics of affect in practices of artful teaching and learning in social education in Denmark”, Arts and Humanities in Higher Education, no. 23, 131-152.
35. Smooha, Sammy (2013), “A Zionist state, a binational state, and an in-between Jewish and democratic state” in Anita Shapira, Yedidia Z. Stern and Alexander Yakobson (ed.), Nationalism and Binationalism, Brighton, UK: Sussex Academic Press, Jerusalem: Israel Democracy Institute, 206-224.
36. Van Damme, Willemien; De Decker, Pascal; Leinfelder, Hans (2024), “Does increasing ethnic diversity challenge the rural idyll? An Analysis of frames on ethnic diversity in relation to rurality in the Flemish written press (Belgium)”, Rural Sociology, no. 1, 132-153.
37. Wattad, Mohammed Saif-Alden (2007), “Israeli Arabs: Between the nation and the state”, Indigenous Law Journal, no. 1, 179–192, https://jps.library.utoronto.ca/index.php/ilj/article/view/27668/20399
38. Winter, Elke (2021), “Multicultural citizenship for the highly skilled? Naturalization, human capital, and the boundaries of belonging in Canada’s middle-class nation-building”, Ethnicities, no. 21, 289-310.
39. Zuber, Christina Isabel (2022), Ideational legacies and the politics of migration in European minority regions, Oxford University Press.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Studia Universitatis Babeș-Bolyai Studia Europaea
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
